If you’re a dog parent, you know the struggle of finding food that makes your pup’s tail wag and keeps them healthy. My dog, Luna, a 5-year-old Beagle mix, is the pickiest eater I’ve ever met—she’d rather sniff a kibble than eat it. So when I heard about Ollie, a fresh, human-grade dog food subscription, I was curious.
Could it win over Luna’s finicky palate? I decided to put Ollie to the test for two weeks. In this listicle, I’ll share Luna’s honest “review” (as told through her wags and woofs), backed by my observations, 2025 user reviews from X and the web, and insights from pet experts. Spoiler: Luna’s got a lot to say! Let’s dive into our 14-day Ollie adventure.
Why I Chose Ollie for My Dog
Ollie promises fresh, vet-formulated meals tailored to your dog’s needs, delivered to your door. Unlike kibble, which can be packed with fillers, Ollie uses whole ingredients like beef, chicken, and veggies, cooked at low temperatures to lock in nutrients.
A 2025 Dogster review highlights Ollie’s human-grade quality and AAFCO-compliant recipes, making it a top pick for health-conscious pet parents. Luna’s picky eating and occasional tummy troubles made me think fresh food might be the answer. Plus, with thousands of 5-star reviews and a 60% off starter box deal, I figured it was worth a shot.
Getting Started with Ollie
Signing up was a breeze. I filled out an 8-question quiz on Ollie’s website about Luna’s age (5), breed (Beagle mix), weight (30 lbs), activity level (moderate), and dietary needs (no allergies, but sensitive stomach). The quiz calculated Luna’s daily calorie needs (about 600 calories) and recommended a Full Fresh plan with Beef and Lamb recipes.
The starter box, priced at $25 after a 60% discount, included 14 daily packs for two weeks, a scoop, and a “pup-tainer” for storage. The box arrived frozen with dry ice, and the recyclable packaging impressed me—though the non-recyclable seals were a minor bummer. Ollie’s transition guide suggested mixing 25% Ollie with Luna’s old kibble, gradually increasing to 100% over 10 days to avoid tummy upset.
The 14-Day Ollie Test: My Pup’s Experience
Luna’s two-week trial was a rollercoaster of wags, sniffs, and happy dances. Here’s how it went:
- Day 1–3: Luna was skeptical, sniffing the Beef recipe cautiously. Mixing it with her kibble helped, and by day 3, she licked the bowl clean.
- Day 4–7: The Lamb recipe was a hit! Luna started doing a “food dance” (spinning in circles) at mealtime. Her poops were firmer, and no gas—a win for her sensitive stomach.
- Day 8–10: I noticed Luna’s coat looking glossier, and she had more energy during walks. The transition to 100% Ollie was seamless, with no digestive issues.
- Day 11–14: Luna was obsessed, gobbling every bite. I even caught her staring at the fridge! Her stools stayed consistent, and she seemed happier overall.
User reviews echoed Luna’s experience. A 2025 Trustpilot post raved about a rescue dog doing a “happy dance” for Ollie’s Lamb, while a MySubscriptionAddiction review noted improved stools in a senior dog after a few days. But not every pup loved it—some X users reported picky eaters refusing Ollie’s “gooey” texture.
Top 5 Observations from the Two-Week Trial
Here’s what stood out during Luna’s 14-day Ollie test, backed by science and user insights.
1. Tail-Wagging Mealtime Excitement
What I Noticed: Luna went from nibbling kibble to devouring Ollie like it was a gourmet treat. The Beef and Lamb recipes, packed with real meat and veggies, had her spinning in circles. Why It Matters: Fresh, human-grade ingredients are more palatable. A 2025 Rover review noted that even picky eaters like test pup Pepper loved Ollie’s pâté-like texture. On X, users shared videos of dogs “going wild” for Ollie’s fresh packs.
Insight: Ollie’s vet-formulated recipes, with single-protein sources like beef or lamb, appeal to fussy eaters and suit dogs with allergies.
2. Improved Digestion and Poop Quality
What I Noticed: Luna’s gas vanished, and her poops were smaller, firmer, and less smelly by day 5. Why It Matters: Fresh food is easier to digest than kibble, which can contain fillers. A 2025 CanineJournal review reported less gas and vomiting in a dog after switching to Ollie. A Vetstreet tester noted their Poodle’s “well-formed” stools on Ollie.
Insight: Ollie’s low-heat cooking preserves nutrients, and ingredients like chia seeds and spinach support gut health, per a 2025 Dog Food Advisor analysis.
3. Shiner Coat and More Energy
What I noticed: By week two, Luna’s coat was noticeably glossier, and she had extra pep during playtime. Why It Matters: Omega-3s from fish oil and nutrient-dense veggies like kale boost skin and energy. A 2025 MySubscriptionAddiction review saw a senior dog’s coat improve on Ollie, and X users reported “amazing” fur after a month.
Insight: Ollie’s recipes, with superfoods like blueberries, provide antioxidants and vitamins, per a 2025 Top10 review.
4. Easy Transition with No Tummy Troubles
What I noticed: Following Ollie’s 10-day transition plan, Luna had zero stomach upset, unlike past food switches. Why It Matters: Gradual transitions prevent digestive issues. A 2025 Dogster reviewer praised Ollie’s clear feeding guide for sensitive stomachs. On X, some users noted constipation if transitioning too fast, but slow shifts worked well.
Insight: Ollie’s pre-portioned packs and detailed instructions make switching foolproof, per ConsumerRating (2025).
5. Customizable Portions and Recipes
What I noticed: Luna’s 600-calorie daily packs were perfectly portioned, and I could tweak recipes via Ollie’s app. Why It Matters: Customization ensures nutritional balance. A 2025 DeliveryRank review lauded Ollie’s user-friendly app for adjusting orders. X users loved swapping proteins (e.g., Chicken for Pork) to keep dogs interested.
Insight: Ollie’s quiz-based plans cater to specific needs, like weight management or allergies, per a 2025 WagWalking review.
Pros and Cons of Ollie Dog Food
Pros:
- High-Quality Ingredients: Human-grade meats, veggies, and superfoods, no fillers or artificial flavors.
- Customizable Plans: Full Fresh, Half Fresh, or Mixed plans suit budgets and preferences.
- Convenient Delivery: Free 2-day shipping, easy-to-manage subscriptions.
- Picky Eater Approved: Most dogs love the taste, per Trustpilot (4.4/5 stars).
- Health Benefits: Improved digestion, coat, and energy, per X and CanineJournal reviews.
Cons:
- Pricey: $4–$15/day, depending on dog size, pricier than kibble. A 55-lb dog costs $59–$66/week.
- Freezer Space: Frozen packs take up room, a challenge for small fridges, per WagWalking.
- Picky Eater Risks: Some dogs dislike the texture, per X and PupJunkies reviews.
- Non-Recyclable Seals: Packaging is mostly recyclable, but seals aren’t, per DeliveryRank.
The Extras: Treats and Supplements
Ollie offers add-ons like:
- Beef and Sweet Potato Treats: Protein-packed, $10/jar.
- Hip & Joint Chews: Great for seniors like Luna, $22/jar.
- Calming Chews: Helped an anxious Cavalier relax, per CanineJournal. A 2025 MySubscriptionAddiction review noted a senior dog loved the chews as treats, boosting skin and joints. On X, users suggested breaking chews into smaller pieces for training. I plan to try the Hip & Joint Chews for Luna’s next order.
Is Ollie Worth It?
Ollie’s premium price ($25–$106/week, depending on dog size) isn’t cheap, but Luna’s enthusiasm, better digestion, and glossier coat make it tempting. A 2025-reviewed article notes it’s not a value compared to kibble, but for fresh food fans, it’s competitive with Nom Nom.
The 100% money-back guarantee on the starter box lowers the risk. If your dog is picky or has health issues, Ollie’s quality and customization are hard to beat. For budget-conscious folks, mixing Ollie with kibble (Half Fresh plan) saves cash while delivering benefits.
Frequently Asked Questions
Q: Is Ollie safe for dogs?
A: Yes, it’s human-grade, vet-formulated, and AAFCO-compliant with no recalls as of May 2025.
Q: How long does the food last?
A: Frozen packs last 6 months; refrigerated, 4 days (14 days unopened).
Q: What if my dog doesn’t like it?
A: Ollie offers a full refund on the starter box if your pup isn’t a fan.
Q: Is Ollie good for picky eaters?
A: Many picky dogs love it, but some dislike the texture. Try the trial to test.
Final Thoughts for You
Luna’s two-week Ollie test was a paws-up success. From her food dance to her shinier coat, she’s a fan, and I’m thrilled with the health perks. While the cost and freezer space are drawbacks, the quality, convenience, and customization make Ollie a game-changer for picky or sensitive pups. If you’re curious, the 60% off starter box is a low-risk way to see if your dog agrees with Luna’s “review.” Check out our related articles for more pet health tips:
- Bone Support Vitamins: The 8 Essential Nutrients for Stronger Bones (2025 Guide)
- Menopause and Cognitive Decline: Why Your Brain Feels Foggy & How to Fix It
- High Fiber Food for Healthy Joints: 20 Foods to Boost Mobility and Reduce Pain
Join Our Mailing List
Get early access to pet health tips, exclusive deals, and new product launches. Subscribe for weekly updates!