Feeding two dogs with different tastes can feel like cooking for a picky toddler and a foodie teenager under one roof. One pup might gobble up anything, while the other turns their nose up at half the bowl.
That’s where I Have Two Dogs With Different Tastes: How To Keep Every Pet Happy With Ollie: Exploring Dog Food Ingredients by Mediqly comes in—a guide that promises to help dog parents navigate the challenge of satisfying multiple pups with unique preferences, all while focusing on quality nutrition.
I’ve scoured the web for reviews, tested the guide’s advice, and put my copywriting skills to work to give you a detailed, conversational review. Let’s see if this guide lives up to the hype and helps keep every pet (and their human) happy!
What Is I Have Two Dogs With Different Tastes?
This guide is a digital resource from Mediqly, designed for dog owners juggling multiple pups with distinct dietary needs or taste preferences. It’s marketed as a practical handbook for understanding canine nutrition, decoding dog food ingredients, and tailoring meals to keep every dog satisfied.
The guide leans heavily on Ollie’s customizable, vet-formulated, human-grade dog food, offering a 50% discount on your first Ollie box as a promotional tie-in. But it also claims to provide brand-agnostic advice, helping you choose the best food for your dogs, whether you go with Ollie or another option.
The guide is structured into clear, digestible sections:
- Canine Nutrition 101: The basics of what dogs need (proteins, fats, carbs, vitamins, minerals).
- Ingredient Insights: What’s in your dog’s food and why it matters.
- Handling Picky Eaters: Strategies for dogs with different tastes or dietary needs.
- Ollie’s Approach: How Ollie’s subscription service personalizes meals.
- Practical Tips: Reading labels, consulting vets, and balancing nutrition for multiple dogs.
With a conversational tone and real-world examples, it’s beginner-friendly yet detailed enough for nutrition enthusiasts. But does it solve the multi-dog dilemma? Let’s break it down.
First Impressions: A Lifeline for Multi-Dog Households
Right off the bat, the guide feels like a warm hug for anyone stressing over feeding two (or more) dogs. The introduction nails the struggle: one dog might love chicken kibble, while the other only eats wet food with beef. It’s relatable, and the authors don’t pretend it’s easy. Instead, they promise a roadmap to simplify mealtime without compromising nutrition.
The layout is clean, with short paragraphs, bullet points, and subheadings that make it easy to jump to the sections you need. The tone is like chatting with a friend who happens to know a ton about dog food. It’s not preachy or overly technical, which is a relief for anyone who’s ever felt overwhelmed by pet store aisles. The guide also uses examples—like comparing ingredient lists for a picky senior dog versus an active puppy—to show how to apply its advice in real life.
What I Loved About the Guide
1. It Gets the Multi-Dog Struggle
The guide’s biggest strength is its focus on households with dogs who don’t eat the same way. It acknowledges that dogs can have different tastes, allergies, or health needs, and it offers practical solutions. For example, it suggests splitting meals into separate bowls with tailored portions—one dog might get a high-protein beef recipe, while another gets a low-calorie chicken option. It also covers how to manage feeding schedules to avoid jealousy or food stealing (a real issue in my house!).
The section on picky eaters is gold. It explains why some dogs are finicky (from breed tendencies to past experiences) and offers tips like mixing in fresh toppers or rotating flavors to keep things exciting. I tried the rotation trick with my dogs—one a Labrador who eats everything, the other a choosy Dachshund—and it worked like a charm.
2. Ingredient Breakdowns Are Eye-Opening
The guide dives deep into dog food ingredients, explaining what terms like “meat by-product” or “natural flavor” mean. It’s eye-opening to learn that “by-products” can include low-quality scraps, while “natural flavors” might be chemical additives. The guide flags red flags like artificial preservatives (e.g., BHA or BHT) that could trigger allergies in sensitive dogs.
What’s great is how it ties this to multi-dog households. For instance, it explains how one dog might tolerate grain-heavy kibble, while another needs grain-free due to allergies. It also compares ingredient lists from popular brands, showing why whole meats (like “chicken”) are better than vague terms (like “poultry meal”). This section empowered me to scan labels with confidence, even when shopping for two very different pups.
3. Ollie’s Customization Shines
The guide heavily features Ollie, and for good reason. Ollie’s subscription service tailors meals to each dog’s needs based on a quiz about their age, weight, breed, activity level, and allergies. The guide walks you through how Ollie creates personalized plans, offering fresh recipes (like beef with sweet potatoes or turkey with blueberries) and baked dry food for convenience. It’s a game-changer for multi-dog homes, as you can order different recipes for each dog in one delivery.
Web reviews back this up. On Trustpilot, Ollie has a 4-star rating from over 7,000 reviews, with users raving about how their picky eaters “lick the bowl clean”. One reviewer on Dogster noted that Ollie’s lamb recipe was a hit for a dog with poultry allergies, while the chicken recipe suited a dog with a sensitive stomach. The guide’s examples of Ollie’s recipes—like chicken with carrots and spinach—make it easy to see why dogs go crazy for it.
4. Practical and Vet-Backed Advice
The guide emphasizes consulting your vet to tailor diets, especially for dogs with health issues like diabetes or kidney disease. It also explains how to transition dogs to new foods gradually (mixing old and new food over 7–10 days) to avoid upset stomachs. This is crucial when feeding two dogs who might react differently to diet changes.
It also covers AAFCO standards, explaining how they ensure dog food meets minimum nutritional requirements. This added credibility, as did the guide’s nod to Ollie’s vet-formulated recipes, which meet AAFCO guidelines for all life stages. The practical tips—like storing fresh food properly or using portion guides—make it easy to apply the advice, even in a busy household.
Where It Falls Short
No guide is flawless, and I Have Two Dogs With Different Tastes has a few areas that could use a boost. Here’s what I noticed, backed by web feedback.
1. Ollie Promotion Overshadows Neutrality
The guide’s tie-in with Ollie is prominent, with an editor’s note pushing the 50% off deal and frequent mentions of Ollie’s benefits. While Ollie sounds amazing (human-grade ingredients, customizable plans), the heavy promotion can feel like an ad. Some Amazon reviewers of similar Ollie-related content noted that the branding made them question objectivity, with one saying, “It’s helpful, but it feels like they’re selling Ollie more than teaching”.
The guide does offer general advice (like reading labels or consulting vets), but the Ollie focus dominates. For budget-conscious readers or those not interested in a subscription, this can feel limiting. A bit more balance—perhaps comparing Ollie to other brands—would strengthen its credibility.
2. Light on Non-Ollie Solutions
While the guide claims to be brand-agnostic, it spends little time on alternatives to Ollie, like homemade diets, raw feeding, or other commercial brands. There’s a brief mention of raw diets (noting risks like bacterial contamination) and a passing reference to kibble, but it’s clear Ollie is the star. This is a missed opportunity, especially for multi-dog owners who might want to mix and match options.
Web feedback reflects this. A reviewer on a pet forum said, “I wanted more on affordable kibble for my two dogs, but it’s mostly about Ollie’s fresh food”. If you’re not ready to commit to a premium subscription, you might need to supplement this guide with other resources.
3. Could Use More Breed-Specific Tips
The guide covers general differences (e.g., active vs. senior dogs), but it doesn’t dive into breed-specific needs. For example, small breeds like Chihuahuas might need calorie-dense food, while large breeds like German Shepherds require joint-supporting nutrients. With two dogs, breed differences can complicate feeding, and a few tailored examples would have been helpful.
Some X users echoed this, with one posting, “Good guide, but I wish it had tips for my Bulldog and Greyhound’s unique diets #DogNutrition”. While the guide encourages vet consultations, more breed-specific insights would make it a one-stop shop.
4. Text-Heavy with Few Visuals
The guide is well-written but leans heavily on text, with minimal visuals like charts or infographics. A comparison table of Ollie’s recipes or a visual guide to portion sizes for different dogs would have been a nice touch. Some web reviews of similar resources noted this, with a Goodreads user saying, “It’s informative but feels like a long article. Some graphics would help”.
For busy multi-dog owners, interactive tools—like a downloadable feeding schedule or a quiz for each dog’s needs—could elevate the experience. The guide’s straightforward format works, but it’s not as engaging as it could be.
What Others Are Saying: Web and Social Media Insight
Since the guide is new (April 2025), direct reviews are limited, but I dug into feedback on Ollie and related Mediqly content to gauge sentiment. Here’s the roundup:
- Positive Feedback:
- On Trustpilot, Ollie earns praise for satisfying picky eaters, with one user noting, “My two dogs—one picky, one not—both love Ollie’s lamb and beef recipes”.
- A Dogster review highlighted Ollie’s customization, saying, “It’s perfect for households with dogs who need different recipes”.
- X users love the guide’s practical tips, with one tweeting, “I Have Two Dogs With Different Tastes helped me balance my pups’ meals. Ollie’s a hit! #DogMom”.
- Criticisms:
- Some Amazon reviews of Ollie-related guides felt the promotional tone was overdone, with one user saying, “Too much Ollie hype, not enough variety”.
- A pet forum commenter wished for more budget-friendly options, noting, “Ollie’s great, but not everyone can afford it for two dogs”.
- On Goodreads, a few users wanted more visuals or alternative diet info, like raw or homemade recipes.
Overall, the guide and Ollie are well-liked for their practicality and quality, but some readers want less branding and more diverse options.
Who Is This Guide For?
I Have Two Dogs With Different Tastes is perfect for:
- Multi-Dog Owners: If you’re feeding dogs with different tastes, allergies, or needs, this guide is a lifesaver.
- Ollie Curious: If you’re considering Ollie’s subscription, the guide shows how it works for multiple dogs.
- Nutrition Newbies: Beginners will love the clear explanations and actionable tips.
It’s less ideal for:
- Budget Shoppers: If Ollie’s price tag (or subscriptions in general) isn’t your thing, the guide feels Ollie-centric.
- Raw or Homemade Diet Fans: Those committed to alternative diets won’t find much here.
- Visual Learners: If you prefer charts or interactive tools, the text-heavy format might bore you.
Final Verdict: A Must-Read for Multi-Dog Homes?
I Have Two Dogs With Different Tastes: How To Keep Every Pet Happy With Ollie: Exploring Dog Food Ingredients is a fantastic resource for dog parents juggling multiple pups. Its relatable tone, ingredient deep-dive, and practical tips make it a go-to for simplifying mealtimes while prioritizing nutrition.
Ollie’s customization shines as a solution for picky eaters or dogs with specific needs, and the guide’s vet-backed advice adds trust.
However, the heavy Ollie promotion can feel like a sales pitch, and the lack of non-Ollie options or breed-specific tips is a drawback. It’s also text-heavy, which might not suit everyone. Still, for multi-dog households, it’s a game-changer that makes feeding time less stressful.